With impressive grace Castlestorm uses father-like humor as glue to bring together multiple genres with the goal of constructing something grander, and ultimately better than the sum of its parts. Unfortunately CastleStorm is a game destined to live in the shadow of the Angry Birds franchise due to the physics based projectiles it blends into its real-time strategy and tower-defense concoction, however this unfair juxtaposition does the game a great disservice. Yet despite how much of a step forward CastleStorm is for both the genres it incorporates, as well as Zen Studios themselves, it is nearly undone at the start by stiff and imprecise controls; which is something that our furious fine feathered friends have perfected.

2013-10-31-123155

CastleStorm is a tower-defense game in the most literal use of the term. Players are take up control of one of two towers and are tasked to prevent the opposing tower from toppling their own. The “meat and potatoes” of the combat lies in the ever present ballista which is used to fling all manners of objects at the opponent’s castle such as standard javelins, flatulent sheep, and even Thor’s mighty hammer Mjölnir. Slinging projectiles form your homestead may be the primary mode of attack, but a true general is never truly alone in battle.

After hiring upgradable ground units which range from standard soldiers and archers, to mounted warriors and air bound griffons, players can charge their enemies gates and retrieve their flag; which is an alternative method to ending most battles. If all this feels a bit too impersonal, you can also take up the role of one of the games Kingdom, or Barbarian heroes and jump into the fray yourself for a short period of time. At any given moment the battlefield can feel either immensely large, or tight and claustrophobic, depending on which method of attack you find yourself engaged in at the time.

2013-11-04-114015

Clearly there are a ton of layers to juggle in the combat that CastleStorm employs, and if were not for the finesse in which developers Zen Studios contributed to the design, its frantic and chaotic gameplay may have been overwhelming. The standard gameplay typically leaves little time to breathe as you are constantly engaged in a sort of tug of war with upwards of 10 ground units, all while dealing with the soaring arsenal of objects designed to take out your fortress. If that weren’t enough, you are also afforded an array of spells which aid your units when they seem to be out matched.

CastleStorm may be the title, but multitasking is the name of the game, and the turbulent action on screen is matched only by the frenzied pace your fingers will need to maintain in order to keep up with your adversary. If it were not for the graceful implementation of these elements in the games campaign, the combat may have ended up being far more tumultuous than fun. CastleStorm’s impressive dexterity distills sheer chaos into engaging and addictive gameplay.

2013-10-30-232543

Constructing the castles themselves can be as strategic a venture as the combat itself. The rooms you select to build your fortress out The rooms you select to build your fortress out of, in conjunction with your choice of equipment will dictate which units, spells, bonuses and projectiles you can call upon in battle . Furthermore nearly all unlocks are upgradable using coins that are earned in combat. In addition to a focus on selection, it is also imperative that you are mindful of each rooms placement because once they are destroyed as are the corresponding additions they bring to your army.  For the meticulous adjusting the layout of the fortress can give an advantage in each round of combat; however an assortment pre-built castles are made available for those just interested in action.

With the ease in which CastleStorm handles its many varieties of gameplay, it is surprising that the aspect it struggles with most is the most fundamental part of its design; the ballista. The ever-present weapon is the first that players are introduced to and is essential to winning most battler; however the means in which it handles can be described as clumsy at best. Using the left analog stick players can directly aim their projectiles of choice using a guiding line, and for precise changes the d-pad is used to slightly correct the aim.

2013-11-04-111347

Having a pair of aiming options may sound effortless, but in practice lining up a simple shot can be frustratingly uneven. Whether you are using the unruly left stick, or the overly slow d-pad; nothing feels intuitive. I understand that the developers are asking players to use both, but given the scale of the field as well as the speed in which enemies approach, it can be extremely difficult to line up a simple shot with the standard javelin, especially early on.

It seems as though lining up a shot would have been much easier had Zen Studios made better use of the PlayStation Vita’s touch screen, which is something that they were not afforded when the game launched on the Xbox 360. While shooting in general can be done with a tap, it lacks the precision needed to deal with the (at times) difficult waves of enemies. It is disappointing that such a simple addition to the controls may have fixed the persistent problem, but thankfully the lackluster aiming becomes less of an issue as you unlock better soldiers and far more powerful projectiles that require far less pin point accuracy.

2013-11-01-070601

In all regards CastleStorm is a light-hearted affair, from its colorful design and whimsical soundtrack (produced and composed by Christian M Krogsvold aka Waterflame of Towerfall fame) to its in-joke laden campaign, it all plays out similarly to a Saturday morning cartoon. The overarching plot tells a tale of kingdoms divided, but truthfully each mission serves only to introduce the player to new layers of gameplay.

Some may be disappointed by the lack of a deep story-mode, but the truth is that I didn’t miss it. The story cut scenes-though shallow-are just short and funny enough to tie the missions together, and keeps momentum moving forward. Apart from the narrative, the campaign does a great job of mixing up the already mixed up gameplay. Rather than have each adventure be an exercise in large-scale warfare, there are great deal of side missions which include many moments of brevity including hunting for turkeys as the hero, and capturing a group of donkeys for battle.

2013-11-01-113922
All missions are graded in a five-star system based upon the speed of completion, as well as your ability to meet a pair of pre-dispatched goals. By exploring the many facets of the its design in the campaign, CastleStorm allows players to gradually become comfortable with its many mechanics without an intrusive tutorial. It should also be mentioned that while the campaign may seem short to those keen enough to keep track of unlocks, there is a whole second campaign that adds to the games length. It should also be noted that while trophies are easy to come by in CastleStorm, there is no platinum for hunters to chase.

Where CastleStorm truly excels is when another is brought into the fold. Adding another human into the fray can make the already chaotic experience even crazier, but feverish nature of the gameplay is still a joy. Whether you are going head to head or working cooperatively on the battlefield or as heroes; the fun (and the difficulty) is multiplied exponentially. Playing with fellow TVL writer Tyler Olthoff we found ourselves cursing, laughing, and cheering as we made our way past endless waves of enemies. There is truly something for everyone in the multiplayer, and enough to keep players returning long after they’ve finished the campaign, although it would have been nice to see support for more than just two players online.

2013-11-01-113932
Despite having some mildly-annoying issues, when all is said and done CastleStorm manages to blend gameplay elements that should just not work into a perfect storm. As addictive as it is charming, it will grip your attention and seduce you over and over again into playing just one more game. Superior in every way, If the controls were a bit more accessible I would have no issue declaring to the masses that this is the Angry Birds killer, but as of right now it will have to settle for the thinking man’s (or woman’s) alternative.

REVIEW OVERVIEW
Presentation
Gameplay
Lasting Appeal
Execution
SHARE
Previous articleAssassin’s Creed: Rising Phoenix Resurfacing?
Next articlePS Vita 3.00 System Update Brings PS4 Link – Available Now
Our former News Editor, Brian is a massive PS Vita fan. You can find him writing for Canada.com Tech and on Twitter.
  • Love this game had a blast playing MP with you!

  • MorfiTM

    Excuse me, but the way you have written a part of your article can be misinterpreted. The part is: “The rooms you select to build your fortress out of will dictate which
    units, spells, and projectiles you can call upon in battle.”
    That is not true. The rooms dictate only which units will be available in battle. Projectiles and spells not. There are only 4 categories of “castle material”: gates (9 kinds), structural (9 kinds which can be used to form walls, extra floors/roofs and towers), barracks (9 kinds of rooms placed to train 9 different kinds of units) and castle rooms (9 rooms which give passive effects like generating food/gold faster, managing more units at the same time, making the units attack faster and dealing more damage).

    • Brian Sharon

      Hi Morfi, I completely see where you are coming from and have clarified the point. Thanks you for voicing your opinion!

  • Rod

    Excellent review once again, Brian! Very detailed and infomative.

    I’m a bit confused though, this review (http://punkandlizard.com/castlestorm-review/) of the Vita version claims that you can control the ballista with the touch screen and even descrives it as ‘easy’! Is there an option to change thos econtrols to the touchscreen or were they simply making this up?

    • Brian Sharon

      Without investigating the link (I am having some problems with my local ISP at the moment) i would have to say that if they claimed that touchscreen aiming was available, they are mistaken. As far as I know (based upon my experience, and talking in the VitaCast yesterday with Zen Studios’ Community Manager) touchscreen aiming was left out due to time constraints. That being said, there is the option to pan the camera using the touch screen; although I would not call that aiming. I hope that clears up some of the confusion.

      • Rod

        Thanks for clarifying, Brian. In that case, I’m getting the impression that the reviewer on that site has reviewed the Vita version without actually playing it.

        Here is a direct quote from that misleading review:

        “The aiming of such a crossbow is delightfully easy and the Vita touch screen handles this brilliantly. In fact, the whole game can be played by touch screen which makes CastleStorm a dream on the handheld.”

        • Brian Sharon

          Perhaps the reviewer is speaking in hyperbole, that is the only other thing I can come up with. There are a ton of uses for the touch screen, but most of them deal with the menu’s, not the combat. Although “The aiming of such a crossbow is delightfully easy and the Vita touch screen handles this brilliantly.” is blatantly incorrect.

          • Rod

            Thanks, Brian. Oh well, I can download the trial now and see if the controls feel manageable for me. I’m hoping they do as it looks like an otherwise excellent game.

            Thanks again and keep up the great work on your Vita reviews 🙂

          • James

            The touch screen does work. I just played it and killed the enemies by just tapping them

          • Brian Sharon

            You can indeed fling projectiles at at enemies, but it is in no means a manual aim. Most units either have shields ,or require headshots to take down properly, and while a general shot works out fine – it isn’t quite the 1:1 aiming of say an Angry Birds. This is why I said it was hyperbole.

    • James

      Yep the touch screen controls are superb.

  • James Hall

    I would recommend that people try the demo and persevere with it. Give it more than a few goes, I did and am now enjoying the campaign sooooo much 🙂

  • aros

    You should have described it as Angry Birds For Gamers – I don’t know anyone who genuinely is into games that enjoys AB, the game is awful. Castlestorm is brilliant though and highly recommended. I’m enjoying the full version a lot. There is tonnes of depth here and genuine excitement and action while playing as you juggle the various elements of the battle. There’s a lot of variety in the campaign too, it’s great.

    • Brian Sharon

      I personally detest the word “gamer” – but did describe it as “…but as of right now it will have to settle for the thinking man’s (or woman’s) alternative”. As for anecdotal evidence towards “gamers” not liking Angry Birds, without being ferocious I just have to disagree. Many of the top games critics, and developers have admitted to being addicted to the game at some point.

      • aros

        That’s true, but people were addicted to Snake at some point. It doesn’t mean it’s a great or even good game. There’s an interesting review of Angry Birds Trilogy on PS360 that tackles the ‘addictive’ myth by including how many scores were posted to the leaderboards every few levels. Something like 40% of players played the very first level only then nothing else. If Angry Birds launched on consoles it wouldn’t have been noteworthy at all, except for having a low metacritic average. It was just the right place and the right time, appealing to non-gamers with how simple and shallow it is while appealing to other people’s desire to break things for a short enough time to build traction and get the word out. It’s noteworthy that very few have a *current* addiction to Angry Birds. Like endless runners, they are games that suit phones but would have failed miserably if anyone tried to release titles on a console or handheld. Look at the way AB:SW was praised for it’s depth and interactivity because you got to tap the screen an additional time after releasing the bird!

        I just feel it’s a bit of a shame to compare the title to Angry Birds, admittably in a favourable way, but only slightly, when the game is so much more than a slight improvement on that design. I know the rest of the review covers it but a lot of people do just read the final paragraph. Thank you for the reply though, I certainly wasn’t expecting one! I have no criticism of you though so please don’t take anything above as a personal attack, just ranting about Angry Birds 😉

        It was an excellent review for this title overall though and far above the standard of any similar sites – I’m pleased to see TVL being linked to more and more across Vita forums. Is there a reason reviews here are of a such higher standard than other gaming sites? Most websites just troll their visitors these days!

        • Brian Sharon

          I completely understand your position, and I would never claim that Angry Birds is the pinnacle of the medium. That being said, it would not have had the impact it did (essentially launching phones as a viable platform for game development) had it of had strong mechanics. I think that you are expecting a bit much from a game that was made for early touchscreen devices.

          It may be a one trick pony, but it does that trick quite well – which is why Zen Studios themselves often mention Angry Birds when speaking about CastleStorm.

          Also I wanted to thank you for your comments. We at TVL love to engage in conversations with our fans and appreciate your time. As for review scores being higher here? I can’t speak for the entire staff, but I try to be as fair as possible. I gave CastleStorm a 4.4/5.0 because it is deserving it. There is also something to be said about TVL being a completely dedicated site in that we don’t necessarily judge games in comparison to console equivalents as well; take for example Batman: Arkham Origins.

          • aros

            Ah not higher scores given – higher quality reviews! This is probably the only site that doesn’t ever troll their visitors.

  • Satu Patel

    I want this game so bad, but due to the 100 icon limitation I cannot purchase it unless I delete some other games in which I do not want to. I just deleted an icon to install wrc4.

  • aros

    I’ve really been enjoying this game over the weekend and it’s probably in my top 5 Vita games. Hopefully sales will reflect how great the game is.